Should You Repair or Replace?
Make an informed decision with our interactive calculator and expert guidance on appliance repairs versus replacement.
Should You Replace Your Appliance?
Share This Calculator
Factors to Consider
When to Repair
- Appliance is less than half its expected lifespan
- Repair costs are less than 50% of replacement cost
- The problem is a single, easily replaceable component
- You're happy with the appliance's features and performance
When to Replace
- Appliance is nearing its expected lifespan (8+ years)
- Repair costs exceed 50% of a replacement unit
- Multiple components are failing or previous repairs haven't resolved issues
- Newer models offer significant energy efficiency improvements or features
Expert Guidance on Appliance Replacement
Make informed decisions about your whitegoods with our comprehensive replacement guides
When to Replace Your Appliances
Knowing when to replace your whitegoods can save you money and ensure your home runs efficiently. Consider these guidelines when deciding between repair and replacement.
Refrigerator
10-15 yearsSigns It's Time to Replace:
- Temperature inconsistency
- Excessive condensation
- Major repairs exceed 50% of replacement cost
Energy Efficiency Benefits:
Energy efficiency improvements can save 30-40% on energy bills
Washing Machine
8-12 yearsSigns It's Time to Replace:
- Excessive vibration or noise
- Seized drum
- Repair costs exceed 50% of new
Energy Efficiency Benefits:
New models use 25% less energy and 40% less water
Dishwasher
8-10 yearsSigns It's Time to Replace:
- Leaks or water pooling
- Door latch problems
- Rust on the interior
Energy Efficiency Benefits:
Modern dishwashers can save 976 litres of water per year
Dryer
10-13 yearsSigns It's Time to Replace:
- Clothes take multiple cycles to dry
- Excessive heat or burning smell
- Drum not spinning properly
Energy Efficiency Benefits:
Energy-efficient models can reduce energy costs by 20%
Oven/Range
13-15 yearsSigns It's Time to Replace:
- Uneven cooking temperatures
- Control panel malfunctions
- Gas smell (for gas ranges)
Energy Efficiency Benefits:
Induction cooktops are 85% efficient vs. 40-55% for gas
The 50% Rule
If the cost of repair is more than 50% of the price of a new appliance, it's generally more economical to replace it. This rule takes into account the improved efficiency and reliability of newer models.
Understanding Replacement Costs
When replacing whitegoods, the sticker price is just the beginning. Understanding all associated costs helps you budget accurately and avoid surprises.
Initial Appliance Cost
The purchase price of the new appliance
Key Considerations:
- Basic vs. premium models
- Energy efficiency ratings
- Smart features and connectivity
- Warranty coverage
Delivery & Installation
Professional delivery and setup costs
Key Considerations:
- Standard delivery fees ($50-$150)
- Installation charges ($100-$300)
- Haul-away of old appliance
- Any required modifications
Disposal Fees
Cost to properly dispose of old appliance
Key Considerations:
- Local council disposal fees ($20-$50)
- Retailer haul-away services ($25-$75)
- Environmental recycling programs
- Donation options for working appliances
Home Modifications
Changes needed to accommodate new appliance
Key Considerations:
- Electrical upgrades
- Plumbing adjustments
- Cabinet modifications
- Flooring protection
Money-Saving Tips
Time Your Purchase
Shop during major sales events like Black Friday, end of financial year, or when new models are released
Bundle Purchases
Buy multiple appliances together for package discounts
Consider Floor Models
Display models can offer 10-30% savings with full warranty
Check for Rebates
Look for energy efficiency rebates from government programs
Negotiate
Many retailers are willing to negotiate on price, especially for multiple items
Need Personalized Advice?
Our experienced technicians can provide a personalised assessment of your appliance.